A little break from the picture posts of Josiah for a moment of more intellectual depth . . .
I've been reading E. M. Forster's
Howards End in the precious few free naptimes I have before school starts. In a 20th century English novel class in college I read
A Passage to India, but before this summer I hadn't pursued anything else by Forster. I breezed through
A Room with a View and am now enjoying the personalities and philosophic musings in
Howards End. The following quote struck me in particular:
"The feudal ownership of land did bring dignity, whereas the modern ownership of movables is reducing us again to a nomadic horde. We are reverting to the civilization of luggage, and historians of the future will note how the middle classes accreted possessions without taking root in the earth, and may find in this the secret of their imaginative poverty."
Interesting that Forster made this observation at the beginning of the 20th century--and here we are in the 21st with a more mobile society than perhaps he even imagined. (I believe statistically Americans move once every seven years.) I agree with Forster that our tendency to cling to our movable baggage, though often motivated by sentiment, becomes sometimes a bit absurd. I've been plagued by the reluctance to purge, and so we store in closets and attics and boxes and under beds all manner of things: childhood drawings, broken toys, disheveled books, outdated clothes, seldom-used tools, and, of course, the luggage itself that we need to pack everything in when we next move! Yes, a good bit of this is worth keeping. But am I accumulating stuff and fostering an unhealthy sense of transience with a focus on luggage rather than on place? I'd probably do well to mull over the idea of place vs. possessions a bit more . . . .
This idea reminds me of something college friends and I might have discussed in Dr. Edwards' classes or the ISI "Fugitives" book club I was a part of during my time at Grove City. And I've certainly hauled my fair share of luggage--mainly books and notebooks full of notes--from those days!